Phones
Facebook Marketplace vs mail-in buyback: which is better for selling a phone?

Selling your phone on Facebook Marketplace can get you more money than any buyback service. It can also cost you the phone. Here's what each route really involves, so you can pick.
The trade-off
| Facebook Marketplace | Mail-in buyback | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Usually highest, after haggling | Fixed quote, locked for 14 days |
| Time | Photos, messages, lowball offers, meetups | About 5 minutes, then drop the box at Canada Post |
| Payment | Cash or e-Transfer from a stranger | Interac e-Transfer from a business |
| Risk | Fake cash, no-shows, robbery | Device revalued if the condition is different |
| Cracked or locked phones | Hard to sell | Cracked yes, locked no |
What Canadian police are warning about
- Counterfeit cash: in October 2026, an Ontario man lost $1,900 after being paid in fake $100 bills for a phone he sold on Facebook Marketplace (CP24).
- Fake phones swapped in: Richmond RCMP warned about scammers using sleight of hand to swap a real iPhone for a fake one (CTV News).
- Robberies at meetups: Vancouver police reported a Marketplace seller robbed at gunpoint in a coffee shop (CTV News).
If you sell on Marketplace, do it safely
- Meet at a police exchange zone. Coquitlam RCMP, Edmonton and Ottawa police all have one. Check the hours first.
- Never meet at your home.
- Take an e-Transfer and wait until it lands before handing over the phone.
- If you take cash, check every bill. The Bank of Canada says to feel, look and flip.
- Bring a friend.
When mail-in makes more sense
- You don't want to deal with strangers or lowball offers.
- Your phone is cracked, has a weak battery or is still financed.
- You want it done today.
Skip the meetup.
Get a fixed offer in 30 seconds, ship it free, get paid by e-Transfer.
Police warnings from the sources linked above. SmartSource terms as of Nov 19, 2026.
Related guides
Same tech, way less money
Every refurbished and pre-owned device is tested by real technicians, backed by up to a 1-year warranty and 14-day returns.





