Phones

Apple vs Best Buy vs carriers vs cash: where to sell your phone, compared honestly

Man packing a device into a shipping box

There's no single best place to sell a phone. It depends on whether you want cash or credit, how much effort you'll put in, and how much risk you'll take. Here's every option, including the ones where we're not the best pick.

The options at a glance

Option You get Speed Effort Risk
Carrier trade-in (Bell, TELUS, Rogers, Fido) Bill credit or store certificate 1 to 3 billing cycles Low, with an upgrade Low
Apple Trade In Apple credit or Apple Gift Card 3 to 5 business days after Apple gets it Low Low
Best Buy trade-in Best Buy gift card Same day, in store Store visit Low
Facebook Marketplace or Kijiji Cash, usually the most Days to weeks High Scams, no-shows, fake cash
Mail-in buyer (like SmartSource) Interac e-Transfer 24 hours to 2 business days after arrival Low Low

Where we lose

  • Apple on the newest iPhones. On the iPhone 17 Pro and 17 Pro Max, Apple's top trade-in credit is higher than our top cash offer. See the table below. If you're buying a new iPhone from Apple anyway, check their offer.
  • Selling privately. If you have the time and you're careful, a private sale usually gets the most money.
  • Carrier promos. When a carrier stacks a bonus on top of the trade-in, it can beat any cash buyer.

Apple Trade In vs our cash offer

Apple's "up to" values are from apple.com/ca, checked November 19, 2026. Apple's fine print says the real value depends on condition and configuration. Ours are Like New cash offers at the smallest and largest storage.

iPhone Apple credit (up to) Our cash, base storage Our cash, top storage
iPhone 17 Pro MaxiPhone 17 Pro Max $1,500 $1,130 256GB $1,425 2TB
iPhone 17 ProiPhone 17 Pro $1,255 $1,040 256GB $1,245 1TB
iPhone AiriPhone Air $875 $800 256GB $970 1TB
iPhone 17iPhone 17 $855 $800 256GB $864 512GB
iPhone 16 Pro MaxiPhone 16 Pro Max $1,015 $860 256GB $1,065 1TB
iPhone 16 ProiPhone 16 Pro $865 $680 128GB $905 1TB
iPhone 16iPhone 16 $695 $595 128GB $715 512GB
iPhone 16eiPhone 16e $475 $385 128GB $520 512GB
iPhone 15 Pro MaxiPhone 15 Pro Max $795 $660 256GB $845 1TB
iPhone 15 ProiPhone 15 Pro $675 $545 128GB $700 1TB
iPhone 15iPhone 15 $450 $425 128GB $510 512GB
iPhone 14 Pro MaxiPhone 14 Pro Max $605 $505 128GB $625 1TB
iPhone 14 ProiPhone 14 Pro $490 $434 128GB $550 1TB
iPhone 14iPhone 14 $325 $325 128GB $395 512GB
iPhone 13 ProiPhone 13 Pro $385 $345 128GB $450 1TB
iPhone 13iPhone 13 $285 $245 128GB $312 512GB

Best Buy

Best Buy pays trade-ins as a Best Buy gift card, in store. Values change often, so check Best Buy's trade-in page the same day you compare.

So who should you sell to?

  • Buying a new iPhone from Apple, and trading in a 17 Pro or 17 Pro Max? Check Apple Trade In first.
  • Upgrading with your carrier and there's a big bonus? Take the carrier deal.
  • Want the most money and have time? Sell privately, and meet at a police exchange zone.
  • Want cash fast with no meetups, or your phone is cracked, financed or old? That's what we're built for.

Compare for yourself.

Our quote takes 30 seconds and you're not committed to anything.

Get my offer

Competitor terms from their own sites, checked Nov 19, 2026. SmartSource prices are our live offers on Nov 19, 2026.

Same tech, way less money

Every refurbished and pre-owned device is tested by real technicians, backed by up to a 1-year warranty and 14-day returns.

Get a trade-in quote

Keep reading

Get the good stuff, skip the spam

One email a week: new guides, price drops on refurbished & pre-owned tech, and fixes that save you a repair bill.